Quick Comparison: Topological Sort vs Quick Union

Feature Topological Sort Quick Union (Disjoint Set Union)
Purpose Order nodes respecting dependency (DAGs only) Find connected components and detect cycles (undirected graphs)
Works on Directed graphs (DAGs) Undirected graphs
Detects cycle? ✅ (if cannot topologically sort, cycle detected) ✅ (when two nodes already share a parent, cycle detected)
Handles direction of edges? ✅ (Direction matters: u ➔ v) ❌ (Ignores direction: just connected or not)
Output Ordered list of nodes ([u, v, w]) Connected components or cycle detection
Common Use Cases Course scheduling, build systems, dependency resolution Kruskal’s MST, dynamic connectivity, union-find problems
Time Complexity O(V + E) Nearly O(1) per operation (amortized with path compression)
Space Complexity O(V + E) O(V)

🏩 Conceptual Difference

Topological Sort Quick Union
Respect dependency order
Is everything connected?
Detects directed cycles?

⚙️ Algorithm Core Ideas

➔ Topological Sort (for DAGs)

Two common ways: - BFS with indegree array. - DFS with recursion + post-order.


➔ Quick Union (Disjoint Set Union)


🚀 Visual Example

Imagine the same input:

Courses: 0 -> 1 -> 2
Topological Sort Quick Union
What happens? Outputs [0, 1, 2] (order matters) Simply groups them together (connection matters, not order)
Why? Because 0 must finish before 1, and 1 before 2 Only cares that they’re connected
Cycle detection? If a back edge exists (e.g., 2 ➔ 0) → cycle If trying to connect two nodes already connected → cycle

🧪 Analogy


📜 Summary

Question Answer
Are they solving the same problem?
Do both detect cycles? ✅ (in different contexts)
Which one should I use for Course Schedule (directed graph)? Topological Sort
Which one is faster per operation? Quick Union (amortized ~O(1)) ✅
Which one handles dependency ordering? Topological Sort

✅ Final Mental Model

Topological Sort Quick Union
Graph Type Directed Undirected
Goal Respect order, detect cycles Connect components, detect undirected cycles
Typical Problems Scheduling, compilation order Kruskal’s MST, dynamic connectivity