Feature | Topological Sort | Quick Union (Disjoint Set Union) |
---|---|---|
Purpose | Order nodes respecting dependency (DAGs only) | Find connected components and detect cycles (undirected graphs) |
Works on | Directed graphs (DAGs) | Undirected graphs |
Detects cycle? | ✅ (if cannot topologically sort, cycle detected) | ✅ (when two nodes already share a parent, cycle detected) |
Handles direction of edges? | ✅ (Direction matters:
u ➔ v ) |
❌ (Ignores direction: just connected or not) |
Output | Ordered list of nodes
([u, v, w] ) |
Connected components or cycle detection |
Common Use Cases | Course scheduling, build systems, dependency resolution | Kruskal’s MST, dynamic connectivity, union-find problems |
Time Complexity | O(V + E) | Nearly O(1) per operation (amortized with path compression) |
Space Complexity | O(V + E) | O(V) |
Topological Sort | Quick Union | |
---|---|---|
Respect dependency order | ✅ | ❌ |
Is everything connected? | ❌ | ✅ |
Detects directed cycles? | ✅ | ❌ |
Two common ways: - BFS with indegree array. - DFS with recursion + post-order.
Imagine the same input:
Courses: 0 -> 1 -> 2
Topological Sort | Quick Union | |
---|---|---|
What happens? | Outputs [0, 1, 2] (order matters) | Simply groups them together (connection matters, not order) |
Why? | Because 0 must finish before 1, and 1 before 2 | Only cares that they’re connected |
Cycle detection? | If a back edge exists (e.g., 2 ➔ 0) → cycle | If trying to connect two nodes already connected → cycle |
Question | Answer |
---|---|
Are they solving the same problem? | ❌ |
Do both detect cycles? | ✅ (in different contexts) |
Which one should I use for Course Schedule (directed graph)? | Topological Sort ✅ |
Which one is faster per operation? | Quick Union (amortized ~O(1)) ✅ |
Which one handles dependency ordering? | Topological Sort ✅ |
Topological Sort | Quick Union | |
---|---|---|
Graph Type | Directed | Undirected |
Goal | Respect order, detect cycles | Connect components, detect undirected cycles |
Typical Problems | Scheduling, compilation order | Kruskal’s MST, dynamic connectivity |